Advantages of open intake are noise and a lot easier to clean. I have the APR one because I have APR tune and wanted everything to match but it's super quiet. Have to take it all apart to clean too. Also, the carbon fiber looks nice but, IMO, really doesn't belong in the engine bay of a GTI. The stage 2 pipe is for looks only. If anything, it's another thing to worry about because the PCV vent hose fitting is known to leak on it.
I honestly don't think it makes any real difference which one you go with. So why did I buy APR? Because it was on sale, the tuner I found was an APR dealer, and I wanted it to match.
I honestly don't think it makes any real difference which one you go with. So why did I buy APR? Because it was on sale, the tuner I found was an APR dealer, and I wanted it to match.