I was hoping to do option 4 but here is the deal. The dealership is called stohlman automotive and vw and subaru are under the same roof. I was leasing a jetta before i got into my gti lease. I was able to leave my jetta lease with no penalties with 1.5 years remaining. But this time im looking to get into a subaru do you guys think that ill be able to get away with no penalties? Ill be going in to talk with sometime next week but i just wanted to get your opinions. Im not in a hurry to leave my gti lease at all just exploring my options and thanks for your responses guys!
Any dealer will take a lease as a trade, but you will have to make up any difference between what they think the car is worth on trade-in and what the current lease buyout is. It doesn't have to be with a dealer that is a VW dealer or associated with one.
As an example, say the Subaru has an MSRP of $30,000 and you negotiate the price down to $27,000. Assume your VW lease buyout at this time is $20,000; you negotiate the VW trade-in and the best they will do is $18,000. Then the Subaru is going to be $27,000 + $2,000 (trade-in value vs buyout value) = $29,000 before taxes, tags, and title.
If you have a Carmax nearby, I would take your car there and have them shoot you a value. Likely the amount they come up with is going to be the best you can hope for on a trade-in anywhere else assuming you don't take it in the shorts on the Subaru price.