I literally just took my car in last night for a new water pump. They called me this morning saying it was done.
I really hope there was/is some new info/parts given to the techs before they worked on my car. But given most of the posts in the WP thread, I'm almost positive its a question of when.
If it happens again I don't really know if this "recall" gives me any more peace of mind. It kinda does, but if it's not truly fixed then I'd rather have a car that doesn't inconvenience me once a year.
I would be much more at ease if there were specifics on what the "official" problem is in VWs terms, and what the "official" solution would be. Not just, "We fixed the pump with a new one."
Something like, we upgraded the seals, or our techs now clean and replace leaky oil seals, including installing a more stout water pump, would go a long way with me. I'd be more apt to keep this car and maybe even buy another VW in the future...but unfortunately I don't think even VW knows how to finally solve the problem...
...or maybe they do and this is what this service thing is all about. One can only hope.