Wheel width vs Tire width is always the same debate. Anecdotally I've been having decent result running wider and I've not had reason to tell me to do otherwise. Celicas are running 225s on 6.5" now on street tires. In the past with R-Comps its even more extreme.
Its hard to get a cost effective way to test this though, since its unlikely you will have 2 new sets of tires that you can run back to back, at least for my wallet.
The way I see it, on stock suspension with basically no front camber, you are going to over use the shoulder, one way or another, bimmer635csi used to run 225 ZIIs on his stock width wheel, and his shoulders were wearing twice as fast as mine. Running 255s(or I think 245s will probably be enough) you are not using all the width, but at least you are not rolling onto the sidewall. Its also not as if my tire is not used on certain parts, since the wear is relatively even across, with bias on outside shoulder.