I have a Tiguan, as well as the GTI, and we love it to bits. Traded in a Mazda CX-7 for it.
I think the C&D articles are bogus. A lot of it is based on price, but IMO, the inside of the Japanese cars are terrible. They're fine, don't get me wrong, but this Tiguan (fully loaded) is superb IMO. We got the 19" sport package (its a '12 - so before the R line came out) and the ride is a touch rough, I will admit...but we're not old balls...its fine at the end of the day. Corners better than a CX-7 (which was noted for its cornering and brakes), and is way more attractive than a CRV or RAV4.