OK I have had my car for 2.5 years and still love it. More than any other cars (Honda, Toyota, Lexus, Pontiac, Ford, Chevy) I have ever owned this car strikes the best balance for quality, luxury, sport, economy, etc. I knew when buying it that it wouldn'd be as quiet as my IS or as reliable as my Toyotas, but for what I paid this car is a homerun. I would buy it again and again.
That being said, I am a little surprised that nobody's gripe was power. The chassis can obviously handle more than the engine provides off the lot. The competition (Ford ST, Speed3, and the new Kia ProCeed) all bang out 25% or so more bhp. Most of us have already spent a paltry $600 to get our power output to where it should have been from the factory. To remain the "hot hatch" benchmark VW needs boost hp and torque outputs.