Well it was a good experiment except the IE valve cover is not baffled well enough to be under vacuum. Took it out for some spirited driving and pumped about half a quart of oil into the catch can in about 100 miles. Oh well. Gonna put the catch can output back on the intake side and call it good.
Sorry it didn't work out.
On my end my Son is back Home from University so time playing with the Golf is limited for almost a month, other cars in storage except the Accord.
I reflashed the IE Stage2 but my Son hates it, he found the same drive ability issues coming off idle as you, .... we flashed back to Stage1.
As you suggested, I may ask IE to adjust the specs under 1.5k RPM of the Stage2 Tune to be similar to Stage1. IDK if they will comply.
....I was very surprised how much vacuum the golf pulls at idle. 20” hg. That's quite a bit...
Yup, I know it's very high, I had measured it at about negative 10 psi, that's one of the reasons my hacked intake manifolds kept breaking/leaking.