It was a simple response to a previous poster who was also discussing it In the APR DSG thread. He understood what I was trying to say. Obviously, the RPM drop would not happen on a different transmission because it is exclusive to the DSG of course.
But... That's not what I was referring to. I was referring to the DSG tune causing the RPM drop. It seems like we have figured out that cars WITHOUT the DSG tune are experiencing RPM drop after shifts.
Sorry, I should have been more clear but it was more of a response to another conversation.
I'll second that. I'm running stock dsg software and the apr k04 v3.1 tune and see a slight rpm drop between shifts. It was more noticeable with the 3.0 tune. V3.1 seems to have eliminated mostly this concern. I think the dsg tune folks being hyper sensitive noticed it more frequently, those of us with just a software tune may have noticed it but didn't worry as much as we weren't hyper sensitive to what the dsg is doing. I can tell you it was bad in 3.0 hell some times 3.0 acted like it would slip the clutch and never fully engage the clutches.
I'll comment about the videos I know apr had a lot of difficulty porting the v3.1 software over to mk5 tsi with dsg. So we do know the tune can affect the shift characteristics of the dsg. The comments were to the effect on how much torque the ecu reports to the dsg affects it's shifting. APRs software manages how torque is reported to the transmission. Since we know vw likes to keep things simple and have like 10,000 software variations on the dsg lol, Ill speculate that some trannies will react differently to the same engine reported torque.
The real question to me is it an issue? did it always happen and apr tweaked the rpm display to show it and now people can see it. Is it just normal ageing of the tranny, software issue, etc?