If you had to choose something other than the GTI...?

[Hooklyn]

If new; CC
If used; B7 S4

 

[D Griff]

Hmm, I don't think I'd buy any of the cars you mentioned so I don't know a ton about them, but I would probably grab up an Accord coupe V6 6 speed out of that list. The new Fusion looks super nice IMO.

 

[doveer]

I don't think I can offer much help, a non-sporty car would make me miss my GTI like crazy when the road gets curvy or when torque is needed on command.

Something under the radar that is still acceptable for me would be the new VW Jetta GLI. Subtle sporty looks and excellent room for all passengers.

The new Accord Sport is really nice, that would be something you should take a look at as well.

 

[johnny_p]

G35
328i
1st gen CTS-V

 

[DHS]

Probably a 2013 Ford Fusion with the 2.0T engine.
A

 

[Teddy Redskinz]

Volvo V50 or B6 VW Passat Wagon

 

[Philimon]