I'm in a somewhat similar situation, while I already own my house (purchased it when I was 23), it is in need of some major renovations. I just did most of the kitchen (doing the minor final touches now), but I still need to do bathroom, the 2 spare rooms, landscaping, etc. I don't always have the time to do everything myself, so I have to hire friends and contractors. After doing the roof, windows, siding, floors, kitchen, I am pretty tapped out.
For the last 5 years of my life, my focus has been in cars, modding, enjoying, etc and I am trying to change that and invest in things that will better my overall quality of life (the house).
I just traded my R53 Mini Cooper S in on a 2010 GTI as my MINI was about to be plauged with problems and already have a few quirks that were driving me nuts. I like the GTI in stock form for now and will continue to drive it that way, but my payment did go up some which doesn't help me get the money I need for the house. So how is this similar you ask?
Well I have a 93 MR2 Turbo in the garage that has been my 7 year project. I've invested tons of time and tons of money into the car but I love it to death. Recently I've been trying to find ways to get the money I need to finish my renovations without getting an equity loan, personal loan, running up credit cards, etc, but saving money is a semi slow process since things always seem to "come up."
My options have narrowed down to
- Outright selling my MR2, in which case I will lose a lot of long term invested money, but probably make close to 15-17k off the car (either whole or parted all the way down)
- Demodding it slightly (scaling it back from a full stand alone EMS w/420whp, back to a stock ECU, ~300ish whp) which would net me 3-6k depending on how far I go, or
- Just trying to keep plucking away at savings and just renovate as I can. Problem is, I want to move within the next year or two and that won't be possible until all the renovations are done.
If you enjoy your GTI, I think option 2 is the best bet. While it means you may not enjoy the speed of the car while it's demodded, at least if you hang onto the car until after you close on the house and get settled in, get your bills squared away and such, you can always repurchase the mods that you know you want and build the car back to its current state or greater. Right now I am leaning toward that as my same option, de mod now, rebuild later if I feel so inclined, knowing exactly what parts I will need to get back down the road.
While VW's can have problems or may need extra attention, you could also walk into someone elses headache buying a used car and may end up having to replace worn parts, fix things, or anything along those lines. If you already know your car in and out, I'd stick with it.