I'm usually a leather guy too, but the MKVI I'm getting is cloth, and leather was not even a consideration.
- not only does the plaid look kick ass (IMO), but I love the history- nod to the MK1.
- grippier than leather for corners, where I will be spending most of my time in this car.
- also, not sure what the quality of leather is VW uses. My 10 year old Acura's seats are in stellar shape. Not sure how VW's would hold up over time. Some leather seats don't wear well for more than 3-4 years before they're looking tired.