This is like a what oil is best thread. No one is going to agree. LOL
Kinda true, but...you can't really measure the difference in performance of various oil brands.
For tire shine, you can; how long it lasts...whether it's messy/stays on the tire/etc.
The 6oz bottle of Tuf Shine that I bought lasted about 6 years because it was so good, I didn't have to apply it everytime I washed the car. It literally lasted for at least a month. As others have mentioned, going with a clearcoat/gel is the best way to go.