Although I do agree that the death of the VR6 is tragic, as a consumer who is looking for both an everyday driver as well as a track car (I attend lapping days quite often), I am happy to see it go. The last R32 felt amazing in the city. Off the line you felt like you were flying, partially cause the sound was possibly the most pleasing symphony I have every heard. Corners were taken easily and the brakes were awesome. At the same time though, the car felt heavy, and it was. It was more than 100 kg heavier than the GLI. The fact of the matter is that a slightly tuned GTI was quicker in a straight line than that heavy R32. The car felt fast, but it just wasn't fast enough for the price. Being on the track with one, is an even more humbling experience. In the tight corners, although the body roll was slightly excessive, it would make me feel like I had the best car on the track. The minute that a nice long straight away came up though, I was left in the dust.
If the GTI-R is released with the S3 engine as speculated, the car will just be on par, in terms of speed, with the new WRX which is also at 265 bhp. The tuning gains, though, is where an owner can really get the most of his/her car. Unitronic claims that the Stage 2 gains for the S3 result in 340 bhp. Now were talking STI speeds and more. VW has stated constantly that the MKV R32 was not meant to compete with the rally cars like the STI and EVO. It proved difficult, though, to charge nearly the same price as those speed daemons and not even be able to play with them. We are in the middle of a horsepower vs. efficiency war. The engines need to be small, efficient, and need to pump out more power than the competitors. The GTI-R is definitely a step in the right direction for VW. I would never buy a Subaru, but I would hate to constantly be humbled by those pesky rice burners. Good job V-Dub!